Literary fiction has been providing a window of insight into the inner workings of true love for centuries. One good book like “Pride and Prejudice,” for example, can do more for an inquisitive soul searching for good relationship advice than stacks of self-help books from so-called dating and marriage experts.
The reason for this is simple: literature provides an engaging story with lively characters the reader connects with, and thus the lesson of love is woven into the fabric of the story, making it easier to absorb the valuable advice.
We can relate better with literature than with self-help books. An expert might write that you must take charge of your dating life and get out there to make yourself available. Contrast that with the story of a shy and nervous man who is hesitant about approaching the girl he does not know well but is in love with, and the tension created as his friend tells him she is about to walk out of his life forever if he doesn’t do something about it right now.
Good literature engages the reader. You are drawn into the characters and their adventures, making a lasting impression you can take into your own life experiences.
Though you completely expect to read a good love story in “Pride and Prejudice,” you would not think to glean any productive dating advice from the Harry Potter series. Love it or hate it, the Harry Potter series is engaging and the characters rich and approachable.
Throughout the series, Harry Potter and the other children get older and develop a normal, natural interest in the opposite sex. It’s no surprise that the characters eventually have some dating experiences.
I have read this series to my boys. While reading “Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix,” there was a surprisingly insightful dating lesson I thought was worth sharing. Let me give you some highlights of the scene and some quotes from the book.
Harry asked Cho out on a date for Valentine’s Day. They go to a popular tea shop in the town of Hogsmeade near Hogwarts, their school. Harry had also made plans to meet with Hermione at the Three Broomsticks later that day. He tells Cho this, who raises her eyebrows and says, “You are meeting Hermione Granger? Today?” He says yes and that Hermione said she can come too. “Oh…well…how nice of her,” Cho says in a cold tone.
Cho then proceeds to tells Harry that Roger Davies asked her out a couple weeks before and she turned him down. Harry said nothing.
Then she was telling Harry how she came to that same tea shop with Cedric, her old boyfriend who recently died. She wanted to talk about Cedric with Harry, and really needed to. Harry tells her he is tired of talking about Cedric and that he already talked about him with Ron and Hermione. Cho is then crying and saying that he will talk to Hermione but not to her, and that he should go ahead to meet Hermione and however many other girls he is meeting after that.
Harry was bewildered and did not understand what happened.
When meeting up with Hermione and Ron, he tells Hermione what happened with Cho. Hermione advised him that he was a bit tactless and he should not have told Cho he was meeting her while he was on the date with Cho. Harry is defensive and annoyed, saying one minute they were fine and the next she is talking about Roger and Cedric.
Here is what transpires from there between them:
Hermione: You should have told her differently. You should have said it was really annoying, but I’d made you promise to come along to the Three Broomsticks, and you really didn’t want to go, you’d much rather spend the whole day with her, but unfortunately you thought you really ought to meet me and would she please, please come along with you, and hopefully you’d be able to get away more quickly? And it might have been a good idea to mention how ugly you think I am too.
Harry: But I don’t think you’re ugly.
Hermione: (Laughing) Look, you upset Cho when you said you were going to meet me, so she tried to make you jealous. It was her way of trying to find out how much you liked her.
Harry: Is that what she was doing? Well, wouldn’t it have been easier if she’d just asked me whether I liked her better than you?
Hermione: Girls don’t often ask questions like that.
Harry: Well, they should! Then I could’ve just told her I fancy her, and she wouldn’t have had to get herself all worked up again about Cedric dying!
Hermione: I’m not saying what she did was sensible, I’m just trying to make you see how she was feeling at the time.
Ron: You should write a book, translating mad things girls do so boys can understand them.
Pretty dense of Harry, right? Well, he gets a pass because he is a teenager. But men are pretty dense well into adulthood, too. And though they don’t deserve the same kind of pass that Harry gets, women do need to realize men are generally dense and need a little help (sometimes a lot of help) from them to know exactly what is going on.
Unfortunately for men, women tend to be vague. They drop hints, preferring that men “know” what is wrong with them without having to tell them.
This is a conundrum. Men are dense, while women want them to be observant and, frankly, mind readers. How do men resolve this dilemma?
Harry’s frustration resonates with the male reader because all men are frustrated by they backlash they get from women when they were not able to pass the mind reading test. And like Harry, most men find it easier to just walk away, throwing their hands into the air and wondering what just happened. They also don’t really care why it happened and tend to consider the episode a good reason to say, “This one isn’t for me” (as if they are going to find a woman who is not like this).
So what’s a guy to do? Hermione, being quite insightful for a teenage girl, gives the answer, but also the reality.
1) Always make a girl feel like she is the girl you prefer to be with, even when you cannot be, or have to be with another girl for any reason
2) A girl wants you to believe other men want her so you will fight to make her feel the most special with you.
That’s the answer to male density according to Hermione. And she is pretty spot on. And now what is the reality? That women react on feelings. This is perhaps the most important lesson here. Hermione says she only was telling Harry what Cho was feeling, not that what she did was sensible.
How many men ask “why?” when a woman does or says something, when they should be focusing on the way a woman is feeling in the moment? They all do. Men are problem solvers, so we need to know what happened and why, in order to take care of the matter.
Harry is “bewildered” because he is dense. He is dense because he is wondering “why” this is happening with Cho when everything was going fine. Dense men are on the wrong trail. It’s a dead end to ask why. It is much more productive to consider how she feels.
A woman shows her feelings when her peace, comfort, and safety are disrupted. Men, it is up to you to get in the habit of practicing the consideration of a woman’s feelings. Only then can you hope to empathize.
Hermione basically says that Harry needs to put himself in Cho’s shoes in order to know what she is feeling. He would then have much more valuable information to make a productive decision, and avoid the classic bewilderment all men are inclined to when a woman does or says something they just don’t understand.
You cannot become a mind reader, and women should never expect this of men (and should definitely share more specific information with men if they want to be understood). But you can become more observant, and you can stop being so shocked when a woman behaves this way. It is how they are. Embrace that and put in what is necessary to help avoid situations like Harry and Cho experienced.